Written by Many people confuse the terms US Green Card and U.S. Residency, assuming they mean the same thing. However, while a Green Card is a form of U.S. residency, not all U.S. residents hold a Green Card. This article explores the key differences between a Green Card holder (Permanent Resident) and a U.S. Resident (including temporary and tax residents) in terms of legal status, rights, obligations, and paths to citizenship.
Green Card Holder (Permanent Resident)
A Green Card is an official document that grants non-citizens the right to live and work permanently in the United States. It is issued by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and provides long-term immigration benefits.
Key Features of Green Card Holders
- Legal Status: Green Card holders are considered lawful permanent residents (LPRs), meaning they can stay in the U.S. indefinitely as long as they comply with immigration laws.
- Employment Rights: They can work in any job, switch employers freely, and start their own business without needing visa sponsorship.
- Travel Freedom: They can leave and re-enter the U.S. without a visa, but prolonged absences (over six months) may raise concerns about abandoning residency.
- Family Sponsorship: They can sponsor close family members (spouse and unmarried children) for a Green Card.
- Path to Citizenship: After five years (or three years if married to a U.S. citizen), Green Card holders can apply for U.S. naturalization to become citizens.
- Tax Obligations: Green Card holders must file U.S. taxes on worldwide income, regardless of where they live or work.
Despite being permanent residents, Green Card holders are not U.S. citizens, meaning they cannot vote in federal elections, hold certain government jobs, or apply for a U.S. passport.
U.S. Residency (Temporary & Tax Residency)
U.S. Residency is a broader term that includes both permanent and temporary residents. A U.S. resident may have legal status under different types of visas or even be classified as a tax resident without holding a Green Card.
Types of U.S. Residents
- Temporary Residents (Visa Holders)
- People living in the U.S. on non-immigrant visas, such as student visas (F-1), work visas (H-1B, L-1), or investor visas (E-2).
- They can legally stay in the U.S. for a limited time but must renew or change their visa status to remain in the country.
- Their ability to work is restricted to visa conditions, often requiring sponsorship from an employer or university.
- They do not have a direct path to citizenship unless they transition to a Green Card.
- Tax Residents (Without Immigration Status)
- Some people become U.S. tax residents even if they do not hold a Green Card.
- The Substantial Presence Test determines tax residency based on the number of days spent in the U.S. (183 days in the past three years).
- A tax resident must pay U.S. taxes on worldwide income, even if they do not have a visa or legal immigration status.
- Being a tax resident does not provide immigration benefits or a pathway to a Green Card.
Key Differences Between Green Card Holders and Other U.S. Residents
| Feature | Green Card Holder (Permanent Resident) | U.S. Resident (Visa Holder/Tax Resident) |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Status | Lawful Permanent Resident | Temporary or tax-based residency |
| Duration of Stay | Indefinite (permanent) | Limited by visa or tax rules |
| Work Rights | Can work in any job | Restricted by visa type |
| Travel | Can travel freely, but long absences can affect status | Travel restricted by visa rules |
| Family Sponsorship | Can sponsor spouse & children for Green Card | Usually cannot sponsor relatives |
| Path to Citizenship | Eligible after 5 years (3 if married to a U.S. citizen) | No direct path to citizenship |
| Tax Obligations | Must file U.S. taxes on worldwide income | Tax residents must file U.S. taxes but do not have immigration status |
Which Option Is Better?
- If you want permanent residency and a path to citizenship, a Green Card is the best option. It provides stability, more rights, and fewer restrictions compared to temporary visas.
- If you only need to stay in the U.S. for a few years (for work, studies, or business), a temporary visa may be more suitable. However, you must maintain valid immigration status.
- If you spend significant time in the U.S. but don’t want permanent residency, you might become a tax resident without an official Green Card. This comes with tax obligations but no immigration benefits.
Conclusion
While all Green Card holders are U.S. residents, not all U.S. residents have a Green Card. The key difference is that Green Card holders have permanent residency, whereas other U.S. residents may have temporary or tax-based residency without long-term immigration benefits. If you plan to settle in the U.S. permanently, a Green Card is the ideal choice. If you only need short-term residency, a visa or temporary status may be enough.
Would you like information on how to apply for a Green Card?
Written by 
Written by